Garnier BB Cream: the original vs the comb/oily skin version + Giveaway (closed)!

By Tina A. - September 07, 2012

A lot of virtual ink has been spilled over BB creams in the past few months, mainly reviewing the two Garnier ones, so I figured that another two separate reviews on them would be slightly excessive and, probably, pointless.
Instead, I'm going to make this into a "review/comparison" post of the two versions, hoping that it will come in handy to someone who's undecided between the two.


The Garnier Miracle Skin Perfector Daily All In One B.B. cream (I'm going to refer to it as "the original" from now on) comes in a thick, almost mousse-like texture, that provides very light coverage, virtually working as a tinted moisturiser. The initial feeling that you get when you apply it is a moisturising sensation, but that lasts only for the first few seconds. It takes a while to properly blend into your skin, since, being a thick consistency, it tends to just sit on top of it. What's remarkable about this product is the shine it gives you - a good or bad thing, depending on your skintype and routine. For example, if I layer this on top of a thin layer of moisturiser, it gives the right amount of dewyness to my dry skin, but if I use another product underneath (a proper sunscreen for example, since I wouldn't rely on the low SPF 15 that this contains), I end up quickly with an oily face, which no amount of powdering can really fix!

The Garnier Miracle Skin Perfector for Combination to Oily Skin B.B. cream is a lightweight liquid formula, that's much easier to blend and layer. It provides slightly better coverage than the original and gives a more even finish - spots, though, still need to be concealed. It dries quickly to a satin finish, that can also turn semi-matte, with a dusting of powder. It doesn't give a flat look to your skin, but it's certainly not dewy either, and, in fact, can accentuate drier areas that aren't properly moisturised. You can see in the swatches below that it's a lot less light reflective than the original. One thing I really enjoy about this one is that it feels very natural: I can't feel it on my skin, nor do I spot any cakeyness, even a few hours into it. It also contains a slightly higher SPF of 20.


I've tried both of these in the lightest of the two shades available, and frankly none of them is light enough to match my skintone (I've used some fake tan a few days before the swatches). If you're lighter than NC/NW 15 in the MAC range, then you'll probably feel that both of these are too dark for you. Another thing worth mentioning, is that the original is a lot pinker than the one for combination to oily skin, thus appearing slightly darker.

To sum it up, I've created this little board:



I'm also including a photo of both of their ingredients' lists:


As you've probably gathered, despite my skin's tendency to dryness, I still pick the one aimed at combination/oily skin. It matches my skintone better, it lasts longer and it gives me more room to play with my skincare or makeup routine. I just need to make sure that I've moisturised properly beforehand!

And now for the exciting part: I'm giving away two of the original Garnier B.B. creams to two lucky readers!


In order to enter, you need to:
a) be a follower of my blog either via GFC or on facebook,
b) leave a comment with your username on the platform that you're using to follow my blog, as well as your email address and preference in shade.

The giveaway will be open until September 28th, 23:59 GMT and the winners will be chosen via random.org. Good luck to all!

Disclaimer: the original Garnier B.B. cream, as well as the giveaway prizes, were provided by the pr representatives of the brand. My thoughts and opinions on it are an honest reflection of my experience.

Have you tried any of the two Garnier B.B. creams? Which one is your favourite?
Have you jumped on the B.B. cream bandwagon yet?



  • Share:

You Might Also Like

25 comments

  1. Great post.. I love to see comparisons!!!

    ReplyDelete
  2. polu endiaferon post! bravo tina!!

    ReplyDelete
  3. GFC: Collifornia
    Email: holliister at gmail dot com
    Shade: Medium

    Thank you! :)

    ReplyDelete
  4. great post always wanted to try a bb cream :}
    GFC: alice657
    Shade: Light
    aliceweatherill16@hotmail.co.uk
    xx

    ReplyDelete
  5. Gfc blublu
    Shade light
    katnatasha(at)gmail(dot)com

    :-)

    ReplyDelete
  6. gfc: PELI tselempi
    pelit6@gmail.com
    shade medium

    ReplyDelete
  7. gfc: Cosmetic Girls
    fb: Thanos Emma
    email: cosmeticgirls@hotmail.gr
    Shade light

    ReplyDelete
  8. i obviously bought and tried the original, after all this hype! it was too oily for my combo skin and a bit darker than my skintone. i thought that during summer it would match my skintone perfectly but as you mentioned it has pink undertones and my skin yellow....i definetely won't repurchase it and not tempted at all to ever try the new one...

    ReplyDelete
  9. Great review, I hated the original!
    check out my last post
    http://beauty-is-within.blogspot.gr/

    ReplyDelete
  10. i've never tried bb creams before!
    gfc:Elianna
    email:elianna20@gmail.com
    shade:medium

    ReplyDelete
  11. Hello,dear Tina!That was a great review!
    Thanks for the chance to enter your giveaway!
    GFC :Kyriaki
    Fb name :Kyriaki Intzeidou
    E-mail: kyr.intzeidou@yahoo.gr
    Shade :light.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Άντε να φέρουν και εδώ την ματ ΒΒ να την δοκιμάσουμε!
    GFC: Daydreamer
    shade:light
    kalliopi_el@hotmail.com
    Good luck everyone! :)

    ReplyDelete
  13. This is a brilliant post! When I swatched them in store I thought the one for combination skin seemed a bit lighter than the original which is far too dark for me sadly! I am tempted to try the new one, will swatch again, but am not a fan of the original xx

    ReplyDelete
  14. GFC: Jodiewinyan
    Shade: light
    jodielo@hotmail.co.uk
    xx

    ReplyDelete
  15. i'd like to try bb cream!
    rousalia.prousali@gmail.com
    fb: Rousalia Prousali
    gfc: rousalia
    shade: medium

    ReplyDelete
  16. GFC Maria Oller, FB Constanza Oller de Moore
    Shade: Fair
    connymoore(at)hotmail(dot)com
    thanks for the amazing giveaway!

    ReplyDelete
  17. Great post,amazing giveaway!
    shade: medium
    kaitlyn.dulcet@gmail.com
    fb: Kaitlyn Dulcet
    gfc: Kaitlyn Dulcet

    ReplyDelete
  18. Θα ήθελα πολύ να την δοκιμάσω! Πρέπει να είναι πολύ καλή!
    gfc: katinaki
    katinaki@gmail.com
    shade: medium

    ReplyDelete
  19. GFC: Anastasia
    Shade: Light

    nastjanastja[at]mail.bg

    ReplyDelete
  20. μεχρι τωρα χρησιμοποιουσα τη yellow rose λογω αισθητικου, (tinted moisturiser με spf) που δν νομιζω οτι ειναι bb. Θα ηθελα πολυ να τη δοκιμασω!
    gfc: Sofia T
    Shade: light
    tsofitse [at] gmail [dot] com

    ReplyDelete
  21. Great post! I have only tried the Maybelline BB cream so far, I like it but want to try some others after!
    I follow you on GFC; lcrotchharvey.
    My shade is light.
    thehorsetalker(at)yahoo(dot)co(dot)uk

    ReplyDelete
  22. Anna Wang(GFC)
    anna_joy_wang24@yahoo.com
    My shade is medium

    ReplyDelete
  23. Πολυ ωραίο post !!
    GFC:athina
    email:athina_thiva@yahoo.gr
    η αποχρωση μου ειναι LIGHT!!

    ReplyDelete
  24. Την εχω δοκιμασει (την original) και μου αρεσε πολυ!
    Facebook name: Mania Yucca Gloriosa
    Mail: mania_p_@hotmail.com
    αποχρωση: τωρα που ειμαι μετα το καλοκαιρι νομιζω medium, γενικα ομως light!

    ReplyDelete
  25. Πολυ ομορφο το δωρακι!!
    gfc:eleni brightside(http://rebeautyourself.blogspot.gr/)
    shade: Light
    email:mrsbrightside.gr@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete

Thank you for stopping by!